clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Wednesday/Thursday BP: Should the Giants retire Buster Posey’s number?

New, 319 comments

Either way, no one else will likely ever wear 28 for the Giants again.

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

Division Series - Los Angeles Dodgers v San Francisco Giants - Game One Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

Good morning, baseball fans!

I was reading an article by Andrew Baggarly of The Athletic in which he answered reader questions, and an interesting topic came up about the San Francisco Giants retiring Buster Posey’s number.

Now, in the past, I would have said that that would depend on whether or not he ends up in the Hall of Fame (which is an argument I am not here to either have or witness). But recently, the Giants retired Barry Bonds’ jersey number and he is, unfortunately, unlikely to get the votes he needs in his 10th and final attempt this year.

So that opens the door for other players to have their numbers retired. And not everyone involved in the World Series dynasty era should, but some players who might never make it in the Hall of Fame have had a huge impact on the organization and the community that would make them deserving of that honor.

Tim Lincecum is an interesting one. The Giants have yet to issue his number to anyone else since he left after the 2015 season. But I can’t see that lasting forever. Lincecum was a lightning bolt of adrenaline when the team needed it most and is still one of the most beloved players in franchise history. I don’t think they’ll retire his number, but I can’t say that I can see them issuing 55 to anyone else any time soon.

Brandon Crawford/Brandon Belt: Unlikely, but who knows how the rest of their careers will play out or how their Hall of Fame campaigns will go.

Buster Posey, though? In my book, retire that number on Opening Day. Build the statue during Spring Training. Both at Oracle Park and in Scottsdale.


Old, random MCC article for you to read

The 10 best regular season games of the decade (December 31st, 2019 - The 2019 McCovey Chronicles staff)


How many days has it been since the owners chose to lock out the players?

It has been 22 grueling days since the owners chose to take their toys and go home. If this is becoming annoying, well, it should be. This whole thing is annoying.