clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Saturday BP: Are the Giants and Dodgers actually rivals?

You hate them. They hate you. But are they rivals?

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

Dodgers v Giants Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Hello and happy Saturday everyone. I hope your weekend is off to a nice start. Our rewatch of the 2014 postseason marches on tonight at 6 p.m., with Game 6 of the World Series.

Now, onto a very important or irrelevant question.

The San Francisco Giants and Los Angeles Dodgers are still billed as a rivalry. You only need to check the Opening Day schedule — which features Giants vs. Dodgers on ESPN, despite the Giants projecting to be one of the worst teams in the league — to see that.

But it’s not just ESPN. Giants fans hate Dodgers fans, and the feeling is mutual. If you’ve ever attended a game between the two teams you’re well aware of the animosity between the fanbases.

Los Angeles fans take great pride in reminding San Francisco fans that the Giants are bad. Giants fans relish every opportunity to laugh at Dodgers fans’ “NL West Champions” t-shirts.

It’s great.

But is it a rivalry?

Some would say that a rivalry only functions when teams are in direct competition. The Giants and Dodgers — who are projected to end up at different end points on the NL West spectrum this year — certainly don’t fit that bill. It’s been four years since the two teams jockeyed for position in any meaningful way in the standings.

And get this: 2014 was the first year since the Giants moved to San Francisco in 1958 that the teams were in the playoffs in the same year. It happened again in 2016, and those stand as the only two times it’s taken place. Now that’s a product of baseball’s bizarre playoff formats as much as anything, but still. Is a rivalry a rivalry if the teams rarely share the brightest stage at the same time, and have never face each other in the postseason?

You hate the Dodgers. I hate the Dodgers. Hell, even the Dodgers hate the Dodgers.

But is that enough to make a rivalry?

It’s a question without an answer, but I still want to hear yours.


Did Barry Bonds hit a home run today?

He did.

July 11, 2003: Against the Arizona Diamondbacks, Bonds hit a solo home run in the 5th inning off of Miguel Batista. It gave the Giants a 5-1 lead, and they would win 10-7. It was his 4th straight game with a homer, and his 29th of the year.


Giants links

Have a great and safe Saturday, everybody.