clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Friday BP: Which Giant deserves to have their number retired next?

New, 188 comments

There are plenty of choices from the last decade.

Photo by Jennifer Stewart/Getty Images

When your team wins three World Series titles in five seasons, you’re bound to have plenty of options for potential jersey retirements.

San Francisco Giants beat writer Maria Guardado wrote an interesting piece on whose jersey will be the 15th one retired in team history.

Former first baseman Will Clark is next, before him was Barry Bonds back in 2018.

Guardado listen five options and gave a breakdown of each of their accomplishments.

Manager Bruch Bochy:

“Bochy, who stepped down at the end of last season, posted a 2,003-2,029 record over his 25-year managerial career, including a 1,052-1,054 mark with the Giants, who hired him away from the Padres ahead of the 2007 season. Bochy is one of 11 managers to record 2,000 wins and one of 10 to win three or more championships; the others are enshrined in the Hall of Fame.”

Pitcher Tim Lincecum:

“In September, Tim Lincecum made his first public appearance at Oracle Park since 2015 to attend Bochy’s farewell ceremony. Lincecum received the loudest ovation from fans, a sign of his enduring popularity in San Francisco. “The Freak” became a cult figure over his nine seasons with the Giants, winning back-to-back National League Cy Young Awards from 2008-09 and leading the NL in strikeouts for three consecutive years, ’08-10. He was a member of the club’s championship teams in ’10, ’12 and ’14, earned four All-Star selections and tossed two no-hitters with the Giants. Lincecum produced some of the most dominant pitching seasons in franchise history at his peak, a feat that should make him a strong candidate to have his number retired.”

Pitcher Madison Bumgarner:

Madison Bumgarner established himself as one of the greatest postseason pitchers in baseball history during the Giants’ three World Series championship runs. He carried the club over the finish line in 2014, when he logged a 0.43 ERA over 21 innings against the Royals and converted a five-inning save in Game 7 to close out the club’s third title in five years. Bumgarner spent the first 11 years of his career with the Giants, going 119-92 with a 3.13 ERA while earning four All-Star nods and two NL Silver Slugger Awards. He signed a five-year, $85 million contract with the D-backs in December, so it likely will be a while before the Giants begin to seriously consider retiring his number.”

Catcher Buster Posey:

“The arrival of catcher Buster Posey coincided with the beginning of the championship era for the Giants, underscoring the value of the clubhouse leadership he displayed even as a 23-year-old rookie in 2010. He quickly emerged as a franchise cornerstone for the club, winning the 2010 NL Rookie of the Year Award and the 2012 NL MVP Award. His credentials also include six All-Star selections, four NL Silver Slugger Awards, an NL Gold Glove Award and the 2012 NL batting title. Posey’s 961 starts behind the plate are the most in Giants history, and he ranks in the top 10 in several offensive categories in the San Francisco era, including batting average (.302), games played (1,258), hits (1,380), doubles (270) and RBIs (673). Posey is signed through 2021, and retirement doesn’t seem imminent for the 33-year-old.”

Pitcher Matt Cain:

“Matt Cain spent his entire 13-year career with the Giants, going 104-118 with a 3.68 ERA, though he endured so many hard-luck losses that he inspired the term “Cained,” which is used to describe an instance in which a pitcher throws well, only to have his work spoiled by his teammates. Cain’s record matters less than his three All-Star selections, his 2.10 ERA in eight postseason starts and his 2012 perfect game against the Astros. Cain matched Jim Davenport (1958-1970) for the longest stretch among those who played their entire careers in San Francisco. Only Hall of Famer Juan Marichal (446) started more games than Cain (331) in a Giants uniform since the club moved west in 1958.”

This is quite the list, so let’s have some fun with it, without losing sight of each of their contributions.

Hypothetically, if Posey and Bumgarner were currently inactive and eligible to have their number taken out of circulation by the Giants, what order would you put the five options in to have their jersey retirement ceremony?


Onto some more Giants links:

Forbes lists Giants as fifth-most valuable MLB Franchise (Forbes)

The most underrated San Francisco Giants, part 3: Santiago Casilla (The Athletic)

How every MLB team would use a 21st-century do-over (B/R)

Bruce Bochy reveals favorite Madison Bumgarner memory as Giants manager (NBC Bay Area)