clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Tuesday BP: Here comes the Astros fallout

New, 246 comments

MLB was shaken up on Monday.

MLB: Houston Astros-Championship Parade Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports

What a wild, wild offseason.

Back in November, The Athletic released an in-depth report about how the Houston Astros - winners of the 2017 World Series - were taking a truly modern approach to sign stealing. Houston was using a live feed of the center field camera to determine the pitches that were about to be thrown. A trash can was then banged on in the clubhouse, loud enough to echo onto the field, to alert batters as to what pitches they might be facing.

It was a wild story in which a team took an ago-old baseball tradition (cheating), and multiplied it to a level previously unheard of.

On Monday, MLB concluded their investigation, and came down on the Astros hard. The team has been fined the maximum of $5 million, and will be forced to forfeit draft picks. Manager AJ Hinch and GM Jeff Luhnow were suspended a year by the league, and, moments later, fired by the organization.

The team is receiving lots of flack - justifiably - but it seems far-fetched to assume that they’re the only organization pushing the boundaries of baseball’s unwritten rules.

In fact, the news had barely broke when MLB veteran Logan Morrison took to Instagram to claim that he’s aware of numerous teams that use technology to steal signs, including the Los Angeles Dodgers, whom the Astros beat to win their world title. He also pointed out that this has been going on a long time.

The San Francisco Giants have thus far stayed out of the conversation, though that may be due more to being bad than wanting to play fair. At this point, pushing the arbitrary limits of cheating is a baseball right of passage.

So: Were the punishments fair? Should the team be stripped of their title (spoiler: No, they should not)? How would you feel if the Giants were caught doing similarly? Do you think the Giants have done similarly?