clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Willie McCovey Memorial 2019 Community Prospect List #17

New, 76 comments

Barn burner at 16!

Texas Rangers v San Francisco Giants, Game 2 Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images

Woot, that was a close one! Ryan Howard beats back tough competition from Jacob Gonzalez and Camilo Doval to take the #16 slot.

Our list thus far!

  1. Joey Bart
  2. Heliot Ramos
  3. Marco Luciano
  4. Shaun Anderson
  5. Logan Webb
  6. Alexander Canario
  7. Chris Shaw
  8. Ray Black
  9. Melvin Adon
  10. Sean Hjelle
  11. Gregory Santos
  12. Aramis Garcia
  13. Heath Quinn
  14. Juan De Paula
  15. Jalen Miller
  16. Ryan Howard

For those who didn’t see, Baseball America released their Giants’ Top 10 yesterday and it was much like ours — until it wasn’t!

  1. Joey Bart
  2. Marco Luciano
  3. Heliot Ramos
  4. Shaun Anderson
  5. Sean Hjelle
  6. Logan Webb
  7. Gregory Santos
  8. Alexander Canario
  9. Luis Toribio
  10. Jake Wong

Beyond the rankings, they also included some system best tools (in the print edition) which were fascinating as well. Lots more Toribio sightings (including Best Hitter for Average incredibly enough) a bunch of PJ Hilson, and some Manuel Geraldo presence! Why there was even a Richgelon Juliana shoutout (Best Defensive OF). If I may bottom line their POV: If you’re a Giants’ prospect who played in full season ball last year, BA’s scouting reports probably don’t look too kindly on you!

With that said, Lets take a look at our updated candidates. Click on first name to go to BB-Ref, and last name to go to Fangraphs.

Camilo Doval

Jacob Gonzalez

Sandro Fabian

Seth Corry

We’re down to four contestants again which means it’s time for nominations! I’ll try very hard to put in a nominations post at the top (if I can get near a computer at post time) and then everybody should reply to that post with their nominations. As always, top four REC getters will be added to the next list.

Poll

Who is the 2019 #17 prospect?

This poll is closed

  • 32%
    Camilo Doval
    (68 votes)
  • 31%
    Jacob Gonzalez
    (67 votes)
  • 17%
    Sandro Fabian
    (36 votes)
  • 18%
    Seth Corry
    (40 votes)
211 votes total Vote Now

(Neither Polls nor Comments can be seen if you are viewing the page through Google AMP or Apple News. Please view the Story Stream in your web browser to participate!)