FanPost

Vote! What was the worst lineup of 2011?

In a season of almost unthinkable offensive ineptitude, we are gathered today to answer a question few would ever attempt.  Is it the God paradox? No.  Is it one of the Millenium Prize Problems?  Hardly.  No, today we try to answer a question even more daunting: Which Giants lineup was the worst?


Without further ado, the contenders:

May 5:

Rowand

Burriss

Fontenot

Huff

Schierholtz

Ross

Tejada

Whiteside

Sanchez

June 4th:

Torres

Burriss

Schierholtz

Huff

Ross

Crawford

Tejada

Stewart

Bumgarner

June 7th:

Torres

Gillespie

Sanchez

Huff

Schierholtz

Rowand

Crawford

Stewart

Sanchez

June 11th:

Burriss

Tejada

Huff

Ross

Schierholtz

Rowand

Crawford

Whiteside

Lincecum

August 8th:

Torres

Keppinger

Sandoval

Huff

Schierholtz

Cabrera

Rowand

Whiteside

Vogelsong

August 18th:

Ross

Cabrera

Sandoval

Huff

Tejada

Schierholtz

Rowand

Stewart

Lincecum

August 19th:

Rowand

DeRosa

Ross

Schierholtz

Huff

Tejada

Stewart

Fontenot

Vogelsong

September 23rd:

Christian

Keppinger

Beltran

Pill

DeRosa

Belt

Cabrera

Whiteside

Cain

 

What're your thoughts?  I think the August 19th lineup is particularly atrocious (DeRosa batting 2nd?) although they all are a special brand of craptastic.  And, yes, I know, deck chairs on the Titanic, but I thought this make a fun retrospective on this lost season.  (Note: I have a loose definition of the word fun.)

Vote in the poll!

This FanPost is reader-generated, and it does not necessarily reflect the views of McCovey Chronicles. If the author uses filler to achieve the minimum word requirement, a moderator may edit the FanPost for his or her own amusement.

Recent FanPosts

In This FanPost

Teams