There’s just a wee bit of difference between the excitement that comes with a top-ten draft pick and the 24th pick. The last two drafts arrived with all sorts of fanfare, hype, and anticipation. The #5 pick? Why, the Giants could pick , , or ! Dwight Gooden, Dale Murphy, , and Ryan Braun were all #5 picks! Here are the ten players the Giants might pick, along with a long-winded profile of each! Draft! Draft! Draft!
The #24 pick? Meh. win above replacement. So it’s probably best just to ignore any pick from #24 on entirely.. . John Gibbons. More than half of the #24 overall picks never made the majors. Over three-quarters of the players who did make the majors didn’t even accrue a single measly
What ignoring a late-round pick might look like
Ah. So there is an upside. You just have to keep everything in perspective. The player the Giants draft this year is almost certainly not the next Matt Cain. Cain has already had a better career than 96% of the draft picks selected in the same slot (#25) over the past four decades.
But, you know, the draft pick could be as good as Cain. Maybe even better. That’s just science. So let’s all get our hopes up.
This FanPost does a good job breaking down the different routes the Giants can take, and it makes the argument that the Giants should stay away from high school hitters. I couldn’t agree more. The Giants should stay far, far away from high school position players. Just because the Giants couldn’t develop doesn’t mean that they’ll futz up Kaleb Cowart, but the great high school success story of the current administration is , with still an unknown quantity.
Other than that, anything goes. And, heck, even if the Giants were to draft a hitter out of high school, I’d still assume he’s the next. The lobe of my brain that’s responsible for the optimism-related endorphins is easily fooled.
Here's what some mock drafts have going to the Giants, with a link to the MLB.com draft profile in the player’s last name:
- MLB Bonus Baby and Keith Law - Christian Colon, SS, Cal State Fullerton
- MLB.com - Jedd Gyorko, "SS", West Virginia
- MyMLBDraft.com - Kaleb Cowart 3B/RHP, Cook County HS, Georgia
- Fanhouse - Yordy Cabrera, SS, Lakeland HS, Florida
- Front Office Fans - Bryce Brentz, OF, Middle Tennessee State
- Baseball America - Anthony Ranaudo, RHP, LSU
My pick? Hahaha. I’m just a nerd. But I did watch every Draft Report video on MLB.com, and I came away with two concrete observations: a) I really, really like Cam Bedrosian’s 45-second video, and b) I think this kid has watched a start or two. I kind of want him in the second round because of his pitching motion alone.