Now that we've...wait for it...MOVED ON TO THE GAWDAMN WORLD SERIES!!!!!!!!!!
Who do you start in Game 1? Will Tim's 8th inning affect the call? He only threw maybe 15 pitches, mostly changeups, and I believe I read that he skipped his normal bullpen session, meaning he might not really be thrown off by the extra work and shortened rest. But as nice as it would be to match aces with Cliff Lee, Cain would be ready to go, and Tim has usually shown a propensity to pitch better with an extra day or two of rest.
Poll attached. I voted Cain. Either way the two of them are getting two starts (I don't even consider going 1/4/7 with Tim) and I like the idea of an extra day for Timmy.