Zito is owed 83 million over 4 years (or 94 million over 5 years) and Soriano is owed 90 million over the next 5 years.
Both contracts are terrible, and if I had asked this question last year I'm sure everyone here would have shouted "obviously, where do I sign?" but this year Soriano has been terrible and Zito has regained some of his old velocity and form.
So if this was a realistic option in the off-season, would you want it?
Obviously there's a whole bunch of logistical factors (both have NTC's, etc.) but at the heart of the issue is the simple question of who do you think would help the Giants more over the next 4-5 years: Alfonso Soriano or Barry Zito?
I'd hands down be in the Soriano camp, but out of pure curiosity I just wanted to see where other people fall on this question