No editorial on this one. I'm just curious.
Would replacing Randy Winn, Bengie Molina, and Edgar Renteria in the Giants' everyday lineup with John Bowker or Fred Lewis, Buster Posey, and Kevin Frandsen or Juan Uribe help the Giants' chances to make the playoffs?
Yes on all counts. (204 votes)
Yes overall, but moving Winn out of the lineup would be a downgrade (236 votes)
Yes overall, but moving Molina out of the lineup would be a downgrade (59 votes)
Yes overall, but moving Renteria out of the lineup would be a downgrade (19 votes)
No. The potential reward isn't enough to risk upsetting the veterans of the team (60 votes)
No. The replacement players wouldn't be as good as you think (205 votes)
No. I trust the veterans to improve more than I trust the unknown quanitites (49 votes)
No. Maybe one of those moves would work, but it doesn't make sense to shake up the lineup that drastically (335 votes)
I vote for the "silly" option in every poll because I seek attention and affection (50 votes)
I would have chosen a different set of answers for this poll, so I'm going to vote for this option and then write what my response is in the comments section (49 votes)
1266 total votes