I know we have tried to get baseball in the park together a couple of times to no avail, but today at lunch I had a similar idea. Wiffleball... since it requires fewer people, it just might work.
Personally I'd love for it to be a weekday lunch time thing if possible. I think playing wiffleball at lunch on a friday would be a great way to end the work week, but I realize that it is probably more realistic some other time.
If there is any interest, we can start hammering out the details.
It's funny, I probably should check my own schedule before proposing dates for this thing. I'll be working the Web 2.0 Summit in the city from the 5-7 so that doesn't work for me either.
It seems like any other Friday works for me though. Those of you who have tighter schedules, is there a day that works best for you?