Phpppt
It begins.
The first (that I've seen) mainstream "Giants need to blow this thing up" article. KNBR is aflame with folks pining for the days of Steve Scarsone, J.R. Phillips, and John Patterson. They don't really know that's what they're pining for - a lot of the callers are of the "Why don't the Giants trade Fred Lewis and Merkin Valdez for Dontrelle Willis?"-variety - but that's what we'd get: a whole lot of slop-siftin' in the hopes of finding a single Bill Mueller. It'd be ugly.
Even uglier: Staying the course. And everyone knows it. So I'd like to take this moment to thank Ray Durham, Omar Vizquel, Dave Roberts, and Pedro Feliz for not having a scorching hot first-half before playing to the levels at which they are currently playing. If all four of those players had a hot first-half, we'd still believe. Then we'd have our hearts ripped out again in August or September. I still think there's some good baseball left in a couple of those players, so they picked a fine time to slump. Closure is a good thing, especially in June.
It's time to start picking over the bones of the roster. Hands up if you think this team can put up a sustained streak that would vault them within four games of the division lead. There's one guy in the back, but it looks like he just has to go to the bathroom. We've all looked like that for a couple of months now. This diary asked a lot of the questions that will keep coming up for the next month. Who are we going to trade? What kind of return should we get? What teams will be interested? Who will be the Mark Lewis that blocks the one good major leaguer the team finds?
The first thing that has to be pointed out, though, is that Barry Bonds will not be traded. Zero-percent chance if he hasn't broken the home run record, .000001% chance if he has by the trading deadline. Maybe a team would take the public relations hit after 755 - flags fly forever, and all that - but can you imagine Bonds hitting 755 in an Angels uniform? Neither can the Angels.
With that out of the way: Open Fire Sale Thread. Comment starter: Do you think Randy Winn would waive his no-trade clause to go to a contender?
53 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Re: Phpppt
by fanofvanlandingham on Jun 19, 2007 1:17 PM PDT reply actions
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
And yes, I am aware the Wily's D leaves something to be desired.
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
by beaunose on Jun 19, 2007 2:30 PM PDT up reply actions
Re: Phpppt
by Cynema the Band on Jun 19, 2007 3:18 PM PDT up reply actions
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
by achiappanza on Jun 20, 2007 11:43 AM PDT up reply actions
Re: Phpppt
(Full disclosure: I played with and against Gartrell from ages 12-18, and never imagined he'd perform as well as he has in the Sally League. In fact, if he makes the majors, I'll be telling everyone I know the story about how I started at 1B over him for an entire summer on our Bronco league all star team, and the time when I was 14 and he literally ran through a right field fence in Foster City while I was pitching.)
by David A. Arnott on Jun 19, 2007 1:25 PM PDT reply actions
Yup!
by DrBGiantsfan on Jun 19, 2007 3:51 PM PDT up reply actions
Re: Phpppt
He does make a lot of money over the next two years, but if he keeps hitting like he has, he'll be a useful CFer for the length of the contract. The Red Sox could use an upgrade in CF, though with Jacoby Ellsbury on his way up, I don't think they'd want to acquire someone with Winn's contract status. The Tigers could probably use someone who's not a complete offensive black-hole in LF (and maybe 1B... Klesko?) Of course, the Tigers can live with their current LF and 1B situations (it's the bullpen that's costing them games.) The Mets could use another body for the outfield, but would they really want to invest in someone for the next 2.5 years when they've got so many talented OFs in their system?
I'm kind of rambling, but the thing that sticks out to me as far as Winn goes is that a lot of teams looking for a short-term upgrade might not want to take on the long-term ramifications of Winn's contract (even if it's not that bad of a deal) just because of future players they have coming up through their system. That said, I think Winn could definitely be a valuable addition to a contender and we could convince him to waive the NTC if we found a deal it was worth doing so for.
Re: Phpppt
Veteran players having enough trade value that the Giants could turn into major league prospects/players:
Roberts, Durham, Vizquel, Winn, Feliz, Molina, Lowry, Morris, Kline. Maybe Chulk. I suppose I could include Messenger in this group.
Veteran players having very little trade value:
Aurilia (DL), Klesko, Sweeney, Ortiz (DL). Alfonzo (DL).
Not tradeable/off limits:
Bonds, Zito, Cain, Lincecum.
I've only included players in the first category that should be on the block. Obviously, the team would be able to get something for Correia, Hennessey, Sanchez, Taschner, not to mention current minor leaguers Brian Wilson, Sadler, Misch and Blackley, but none of those guys have reached their full potential as major leaguers and it doesn't seem worth it to trade them now, especially if we're dumping vets.
Lewis, Frandsen, Ortmeier and Schierholtz fall within that group as well, though they could be included in some sort of package depending on the deal.
by nostocksjustbonds on Jun 19, 2007 1:42 PM PDT reply actions
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
BB
Re: Phpppt
by nostocksjustbonds on Jun 19, 2007 2:28 PM PDT up reply actions
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
by nostocksjustbonds on Jun 19, 2007 4:28 PM PDT up reply actions
Re: Phpppt
As much as I love the guy, I think Vizquel has some value. Some teams don't need hitters as much and they could use the best active defensive SS and his charisma. Not to mention that Vizquel is batting way below his career average and some GM's might be willing to take a chance on him. I wouldn't expect a great prospect in return, but any prospect will do, and we have some AAA guys that could take his roster spot.
Feliz is much like Vizquel, good defense, terrible bat. But when he does hit the ball it goes far so maybe we could find a suitor with a small ballpark and an already stacked lineup. Again, fetch ANY type of prospect for him, pay off his salary, and open up another roster spot for a AAA guy.
We should try to trade Sweeney, but if no one bites, then DFA him and clear up a roster spot.
A lot of people look down on our AAA system and its inability to produce position players, but we have several guys that are hot right now and I think some of them deserve a chance to develop at the big level. As if we had anything to lose either.
Re: Phpppt
by achiappanza on Jun 20, 2007 11:45 AM PDT up reply actions
Winn for Sale
Sabean should be dialing for prospects. Calling and gauging interest in a Ryan Klesko (Yankees), Omar Vizquel (Red Sox), Bonds (Angels, Yankees) Sweeney (contender needing LHH off bench), Winn (Mets, As, Indians, Tigers)
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
by achiappanza on Jun 20, 2007 11:46 AM PDT up reply actions
Re: Phpppt
Here's a thought that is begging to be shot down: If Tejada could brought in with out giving up any of the major pitching prospects, would you do it? Baltimore is going into fire sale mode, maybe something could be worked out.
All I'm saying here is that the Giants could field a competative team in 2008 while still building a team around younger players, and there doesn't seem to be any real options for shortstop. Sign Torii Hunter on top of that and Giants management have a couple players they can market. I'd pay to see those two in Giants uniforms. I'm totally discounting the notion that A-Rod will sign with the Giants.
With Frandsen at second, that leaves four other positions to fill with young talent. These seem like legatimate ideas, beside management isn't going to field a whole team of no-name AAA players, no matter what their prospects are. They need to market a team around at least two position players. They will have the money to spend in the off-season and will spend it, so why not Tejada and Hunter?
Re: Phpppt
I think Ichiro is more marketable than Hunter, especially in the Bay Area.
I've always liked Tejada and wouldn't mind seeing him in a Giants uni, but still like the idea of A-rod more.
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
A-Rod...so tempting...such a good fit here...but it just feels wrong. Like a continuation of the Freakshow we're putting on now.
Re: Phpppt
I would keep Molina as well. Maybe Roberts. Maybe Winn, but not both Roberts and Winn. That is about the extent of who I would keep.
Re: Phpppt
- He loves the Bay Area - being a local guy might mean he really wants to stay in the area and would reduce the chances of him waiving it.
- He wanted insurance against going to a crap team or city - would mean he'd considering waiving it for the right situation.
- He and his agent wanted leverage - would mean he'd need more moulah to waive the clause.
Re: Phpppt
. He was with his third organization and might have wanted some geographical security for his family.
. He is back where he grew up, and his parents (and possibly his brother) can watch him play every day.
Re: Phpppt
+ No-trade clauses favor the player and agents get what they can get.
by achiappanza on Jun 20, 2007 11:47 AM PDT up reply actions
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
"Its a limited no trade clause. I don't know all the cities, but I'm pretty sure he'd go to a contender."
Also, FWIW, Randy lives in Florida in the off-season.
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
I bet he'd really consider a trade to a contender if the AAAA lineup took the field once the fire sale has burned out the other deadwood.
BB
Re: Phpppt
Think minor league depth, salary relief, and cheap, passable big leaguers. But acquiring two prospects who will have a .900+ OPS in our 2008 lineup? Not gonna happen.
Re: Phpppt
Your point about sellers not getting much is valid and I think the team needs to wiegh a trade vs. what they'd get by keeping a player and getting a comp pick.
Re: Phpppt
Re: Phpppt
I'm not expecting much in the way of compensation picks next year, regardless of whether or not we trade any of these guys.
Do we really, truly believe a fire sale is coming?
Sorry to change the subject...
by capn roderigo on Jun 19, 2007 4:49 PM PDT reply actions
Re: Sorry to change the subject...
Stupid is as stupid does.
Re: Phpppt
why cant we be on the other end of a deal like the accardo, or joe nathan/liriano deal? you KNOW there is a team out there that has a sniff at the postseason and will trade away future A+ guys for anyone that will help their chances to win. and guys like morris, klesko, and winn could definitely help those teams.
we've got some amazing talent to build around. cain, lincecum, lowry, and even zito is still young. if we could get some hitting prospects in return for the vets, we'd be on the rise again in 2 or 3 years.
by projectmayhem713 on Jun 19, 2007 7:00 PM PDT reply actions
Re: Phpppt
while baer and macgowan need to be held accountable, they placed their faith in their gm's philosophy, which is, development is a crap shoot, so lets draft arms...everyone needs arms...so what we dont use, we can trade for another team's bats
that philosophy has not panned out...and neither has the development of pitching, as the 3 biggest fa aquisitions in the past 4 years have been pitchers. if you are really growing them, why the need to buy.
look...if sabean can pull off a bango fire sale, bringing this team some mlb ready prospects, then, and only then should he be given another year extension....i just dont see him having the energy to pull off rebuilding
and if macgowan and baer dont think the fans can deal with a rebuilding process, unless they can come up with a 130 mil payroll, i dont see the alternative
fans wont stand for another year of this shit, with no future in the cards, and without a bonds chasing henry storyline
and everyone's nightmare has come true...the giants will be hosting the as game, firmly in last place and without any allstars
Re: Phpppt
"they placed their faith in their gm's philosophy, which is, development is a crap shoot, so lets draft arms...everyone needs arms...so what we dont use, we can trade for another team's batsthat philosophy has not panned out...and neither has the development of pitching, as the 3 biggest fa aquisitions in the past 4 years have been pitchers. if you are really growing them, why the need to buy."
You nailed it right there. The worst part is that we already have proof of Sabean's inability to change: couple his repeated digs at players lately (basically "Well, if they'd just play better, we wouldn't be in this mess"), along with the 2007 draft, and we have evidence that he is a deer in the headlights, and the idea of jumping out of the way of the oncoming truck is just too much for him to handle. This will assuredly end badly.
Succumb to Tiny Tim! Adopted dad of Minor Izzy
Re: Phpppt
"but of course, Giants fans will never tolerate
rebuilding, but, 100 losses when the team is trying to win it all, hey, that's fine."
Re: Phpppt
If the alternative is complete structural collapse, you bet they'll tolerate it...
by EliminateMe on Jun 20, 2007 12:39 PM PDT up reply actions

by 


















