I'm hoping Freddie can play well enough defensively in center to play there though.  Randy is really a left fielder.  He plays the corners better than center, and his arm is far less exposed in left than right.

I could see Dan Ortmeier platooning with Nate in right.  Dan hit righties better than lefties with the Giants this year, but over his minor league career I believe he hit lefties better.

If the Giants could somehow get a REAL bat in left field, I could be reasonably satisfied with platoons of Davis and Lewis in center and Schierholtz and Ortmeier in right.  That would presumedly mean that the Giants had traded Dave Roberts and Winn.  Randy has probably grown into his salary and if his limited no-trade could be worked around, might bring a bit in return.  Dave hasn't yet grown into his salary and likely would need the Giants to pick some of it up in order to be dealt.

Regarding Ortmeier, the Giants appeared to be grooming him for first base.  But I doubt he'll hit well enough to be an everyday corner outfielder, let alone an everyday first baseman.

UZR uses data from Stats Inc.

THT's RZR and Dewan's +/- use data from BIS.