Fred Lewis was ranked #78 on Baseball America's top 100 prospects list. I have to admit, I severely underestimated the respect Lewis would garner from the scouting community. The story is a familiar one: boy loves football, baseball throws money at boy, boy learns to love baseball, chewing tobacco rots gums from outside-in, boy turns 58 and finds self signing memorabilia at card show for overweight man-child. Well, that's one version.
Point is, there was always the disclaimer addended after talking about Lewis. Fine athlete, could be a fine player if he learned how to play baseball. It's easy to be dismissive when looking at the stat sheet, pointing out a 24-year old in high-A has no business striking out over 100 times. The backstory also makes Lewis seem as if he were discovered catching fish with his teeth in the Yukon, and hadn't held a bat before. He might have concentrated on football, sure, but he's been playing baseball his whole life.
Still, a lot of people with a lot of experience watching young players are enthusiastic about him. The scouting community can be wrong, obviously. For every Rocco Baldelli there is a Rick Asadoorian, just like for every Mark Bellhorn there is a Jack Cust. It isn't like the statistical or scouting community has a monopoly on right. It is best to go with the Inherit the Wind-style of baseball philosophy, and slap the scouting notebook and Baseball Prospectus together as you leave the courtroom.
There is no shortage of players ranked from #79 to 100 with whom I would feel more comfortable. Ian Kinsler, for example, is someone I would trade Lewis for in an instant. The ceiling might be a dropoff, but the odds of any contribution at all would be higher. As it stands, though, it is much better to be in the Fred Lewis business now than it was a year ago. His year at Fresno will probably be the most intriguing of any Giants hitting prospect.
Tired of prospect talk?
The last person who jumped my claim was found in the Sacramento River, with a tin pan where his sternum should have been. I still hear his screams at night, and they chill me. What was the question? (6 votes)
Yes (2 votes)
No (8 votes)
16 total votes